Sharon H. • November 6, 2015Freshest and best pizza I've ever had. Even better than pizza in Chicago!!!
Sarah • Januar 22, 2020Devour Indy brought me in for my 1st visit to Mama Carolla's. It felt like a classy place for a ladies night with friends, food was delicious and not too heavy, and dessert was a must (cannoli!)
Jill D. • März 26, 2011Great place for lunch. Not as crowded. Also try the take home pastas. Try a pasta and take another one home!
Tim C. • März 1, 2019Delicious Italian food in a laid back environment! The cheese tortellini in tomato cream sauce - yummm!
Say it in Shirts • Juni 23, 2011Ask about Kid's Night (Tuesday's 5-8pm). Tables are reserved just for kids and they offer special deals and activities for kids.
Kellie A. • April 29, 2011Some of the best and most affordable Italian in town. Love the vodka sauce and salad and bread that comes with entrees.
Jason M. • Dezember 9, 2014I cannot say enough good things about this place! I am truly in love with the food here! Magnificent! The calamari piada is the best thing on the menu!
Julie S. • July 5, 2011Amazing food, fresh pasta. Great place, great people. Mentioned that it was my first time, and that we were celebrating a birthday... scored free, made-in-house Limoncello~ tasty!
Kaye K. • Juni 28, 2013They have one of the most extensive gluten-free menus around. Email Chef Kathy ahead of time for the best service...most of the menu can be modified to be gluten free. I have always left happy!
Josh Y. • Oktober 16, 2022The food here is pretty good, especially the risotto. The wine here is good too!
Todd S. • Dezember 16, 2015Fantastic staff ,great food and service, very consistent and an excellent bargain. Best in town !
Bill H. • Januar 19, 2016Always a favorite. Great food, friendly service and a casual atmosphere. I usually get the seafood which is always great!
Violet F. • Juni 11, 2015Great lunch specials! Angel hair spaghetti with a meatball is my favorite.
Travis S. • März 23, 2011Their hummus is the best in town!
Say it in Shirts • Juni 23, 2011Ask about Kid's Night (Tuesday's 5-8pm). Tables are reserved just for kids and they offer special deals and activities for kids.
Mikey B. • Juni 24, 2016The Italian Ice Slush in lemon was awesome!! I also enjoyed the meatball and chicken parmigiana sandwiches
Claire P. • Oktober 29, 2013Tuesdays lunch slices are margherita or bacon with Gouda. The bacon with Gouda is amazing. Not sure about the margherita, cuz, um there's bacon on the other one :)
Kristine W. • Mai 26, 2013Everything was great! Foods was amazing (as well as piping hot) and Vicente V. was over the top with service!!
Steven B. • November 14, 2012The Goat Cheese app is amazing! They also have a great selection of beers on tap.
Tyler B. • April 15, 2013I've been going to the OSF for a really long time. Any time I'm in Indy, I eat here. I always get the fettuccine alfredo. For about $12, you get salad, bread, pasta, and ice cream. It's a great deal!
Felix L. • Mai 21, 2023Beef tartar - steaks
Michael T. • November 19, 2011Baked ziti with spicy italian sausage....it is the bomb!
Kannst du den Ort, nach dem du suchst, nicht finden? Füge einen neuen Ort zu Foursquare hinzu.