The Top Rated Pie Shops in NYC

1. Petee's Pie Company

8.8

61 Delancey St (btwn Allen & Eldridge St), New York City, NY

Kuchen- und Pastetenladen · Lower East Side · 112 Tipps und Bewertungen

nikki: crusts and seasonal pies are bomb. knowledgeable staff who pack every slice with care

Glaser's Bake Shop is one of The Top Rated Pie Shops in NYC.

2. Glaser's Bake Shop

1670 1st Ave (87th Street), New York City, NY

Bäckerei · Yorkville · 63 Tipps und Bewertungen

DoubleDeuce: It's like having a bakery in an antique shop. So weird. But you know that you can't not come here and not buy at least a little something...

Little Pie Company is one of The Top Rated Pie Shops in NYC.

3. Little Pie Company

8.7

424 W 43rd St (btwn 9th & 10th Ave), New York City, NY

Kuchen- und Pastetenladen · Hell's Kitchen · 101 Tipps und Bewertungen

Sarah K.: The Pumpkin Pie was still warm! Delicious! 😍 Their coffee is really good too! I will always pop in when in NY! This is a cute little pie shop! 🎃

Daly Pie is one of The Top Rated Pie Shops in NYC.

4. Daly Pie

665 Vanderbilt Ave (btwn Prospect Pl & Sterling Pl), Brooklyn, NY

Kuchen- und Pastetenladen · Prospect Heights · 19 Tipps und Bewertungen

Luke: So much pie. Would say to try them all, but that's not humanly possible, so share the salted lemon and a daily special on your first visit

Four & Twenty Blackbirds is one of The Top Rated Pie Shops in NYC.

5. Four & Twenty Blackbirds

634 Dean St (btwn Carlton Ave & Vanderbilt Ave), Brooklyn, NY

Kuchen- und Pastetenladen · Prospect Heights · 20 Tipps und Bewertungen

Michael Hoffman: Pie for days. So many ways.